Thanks for the updated information. A few things to note:
1) The OpenSSL version you have installed is out of date and is a version affected by the
Heartbleed
bug. Since you don't have an SSL certificate for your site, you aren't directly affected. If you ever install an SSL cert, you'll need to upgrade your OpenSSL. Otherwise, the version you're using *may* be part of the problem your having, but I doubt it.
2)The reason Facebook authentication isn't working is because your Gavick template is re-including the Facebook Javascript library, and that's conflicting with how JFBConnect has to initialize it's features. In the Autotune -> Error Check section, you should see a similar warning. When you disable the Gavick social integratino features, things should start working.
3) I'm not sure what's wrong with the Autotune -> Facebook App configuration. If you can't set the settings for your Application through Autotune, you'll need to do so manually. Mainly, ensure that the Site URL and Domain for your site are correct in the
Facebook Developer Area
.
I hope that helps get you started. You don't have to run the Autotune Facebook App setup process for authentication to work, it just makes things easier.
Alex