Topic-icon Old comments on new articles

Active Subscriptions:

None
12 years 1 month ago #43589 by mhershorn
We have an online magazine and each month we come out with a new issue. we change the articles attached to menu items. the comments from previous articles are appearing at the bottom of new articles and these comments are unrelated to the new article. I can hide the comments, but what is happening on people's facebook pages? The article they liked is now the new article and not the one they liked from last month. How can we handle the extension to account for how we change articles attached to each menu item?
our site is www.autotrackdaymonthly.com.
thanks,
The topic has been locked.
Support Specialist
12 years 1 month ago #43608 by alzander
Frankly, you shouldn't do what you're doing. I'd really recommend coming up with a new approach because search engines, social networks, and anything else that scans/scrapes your content is going to have big issues with what you mention.

Search engines and social networks rely on content staying relatively static. While a home page with links to many articles, for instance, can change constantly, the URLs/articles that are pointed to shouldn't. A search engine won't be able to locate where content moved to, so if it sees article 'a' for a month and then that content is completely replaced with article 'b', all of the search engine weight given to that page based on the content (keywords) will be lost.

The same goes for social networks. They all use the URL to keep track of comments, like counts, share counts, etc. If a user "Likes" article 'a' and then it's replaced with article 'b', they're Timeline (in most cases) will now reflect that they Like article 'b'. There are some exceptions to this, but there's no way for the Like to keep track of what was on the page at the time of the Like. The other way to think about this is that the comment or Like posted to the user's Timeline will have a link back to the page. So any friend that clicks it will see the current content, not what was there... so it makes sense that the social networks don't try to cache the old content.

I hope that gives you a good background on things. What I'd recommend is taking a look at something like the Joomla Community Magazine . The home page changes every month to reflect all of the new articles. Each link goes to a URL for that article which never changes, even when the new 'issue' comes out.

If you have any questions or comments, let me know. We'll gladly help explain further, or if you have any ideas on how you'd like your system to work, we can tell you if it's feasible to implement with JFBConnect (or social network requirements in general).

Thanks,
Alex
The topic has been locked.
Active Subscriptions:

None
12 years 1 month ago #43614 by mhershorn
Thank you for understanding and being so clear. I have reached out to our template supplier. It is a magazine template. I am realizing now we need to stop using single article menu items and stop changing the articles each month. we are looking at using a category blog under each menu item and then leaving all the articles each month there. the only other way we have done it, has been to put category lists under a menu item, but we do not like the look of the list. the blog look is a little better. i am just not sure how this will look after several years of publishing a new article in each category each month.
Thanks
The topic has been locked.
Support Specialist
12 years 1 month ago #43634 by alzander
I'm honestly glad you took my feedback so well. It can be hard to hear something may being done incorrectly, but my advice is the best I can give.

As for the blog look, it can take a while to get right, but will also give some familiarity to your visitors if the format is similar month to month. I'll completely agree that a category list can be very ugly.

Either way, should you have any more questions for me, just let me know. We're here to help with any questions like above and will help however we can!

Thanks,
Alex
The topic has been locked.