Bryan,
Sorry for the delayed response, and thanks for the PM. I just tried using the Google Login button on your site. My account was registered, I was brought to the JomSocial "My Profile" page and the following message appeared:
Message
Google profile successfully connected.
That's exactly what I'd expect to happen.
Can you test again and let us know if you're still having issues? If so, please:
* Try with a different browser
* Try with a completely different Google+ account
If none of that works, please give us exact steps on what you're using and how to try and recreate the issue.
Thanks,
Alex