The Likes don't just go away. If you know the specific URLs you used to use, you can enter them into the
Facebook Debug tool
. That can show you the Like count for a specific page so you can find the variant quickly. Even then though, unless you want to go back to that old URL completely, the only option is to setup the share buttons to share the old URL and do a redirect to the new URL. That should show the right count, but will also promote the incorrect URL.
I hope that helps, but if you need anything else, just let us know.
Thanks,
Alex