Dan,
Glad you're liking it. The problem is that you're using the Share button, which has been deprecated by Facebook and conflicts when used on the same page as some of their newer features. For more information on the problem, see the article below:
www.sourcecoast.com/jfbconnect/docs/comm...tions#share-conflict
Unfortunately, you'll have to disable the Share button. However, the Like button can be configured to have almost the same look either using the module, or the JFBConnect easy tag:
{JFBCLike url=http://www.sourcecoast.com layout=box_count}
Hope that helps, and good luck,
Alex