Topic-icon [9.0.215 Bugs] bs5 no form-group > to use utility mb-3

2 weeks 6 days ago - 2 weeks 6 days ago #68411 by joomleb
Hi guys, 
PHP 7.4.33 + Joomla 4.2.6 + JFBConnect 9.0.215 - about SCLogin Module

The Bootstrap 2 (Joomla 3) control-group: bootstrapdocs.com/v2.3.2/docs/base-css.html#forms here an image for you


With Bootstrap 4 it began form-group.

In Bootstrap 5 (Joomla 4) the form-group has been replaced stackoverflow.com/a/67655097  and, file …/modules/mod_sclogin/tmpl/joomlaLogin_vertical.php, the mb-3 utility should be used instead, I add here an image for you with details and the “fixed” file.

Do you agree ?
Please, Can you add it for the upcoming next release ?
Attachments:
Last edit: 2 weeks 6 days ago by joomleb.
Support Specialist
2 weeks 4 days ago #68421 by mel
We model our login view templates after mod_login, which still uses form-group for Joomla 4. I will have to investigate this further.

-Melissa
Hi Mel, 
Thank you for your answer. I'll stay tuned here...
Hi Mel,
thinking it's important to be able to make the correct decisions here (as much in line as possible with Joomla 4.x), I want to report my ticket on Joomla GitHub:
- #39641 - github.com/joomla/joomla-cms/issues/39641

which resulted in these requests:
- #39669 - github.com/joomla/joomla-cms/pull/39669

So that you too can participate...
Support Specialist
I'm watching that thread. Unfortunately, I'll be upfront and make sure you know that we are not designers. We lean on the work that the Joomla team does and extend that functionality/design.. but I don't have much input on those 2 threads after reading through them.

If a pull request is finalized, we'll gladly investigate the changes we'd need to make to implement them in JFBConnect for even better integration.

Thanks,
Alex
Hi Alex,
I didn't report the threads because you are a "designer". I flagged the threads because:

- I have reported (here and elsewhere) to Mel several inconsistencies with Joomla 4 and Bootstrap 5
- Mel made himself available and kindly tried to fix all the points (both with release 9.0.215 and now)
- Here (and elsewhere) we are left with Mel who "I will have to investigate this further..."
- I noticed and reported some inconsistencies / bugs (Login page / Login module)
- Here specificlaly, we are talking here about SCLogin.
- The basic concept is that JFBC is built "on the features" of Joomla 4
- For you and Mel to make the best decisions here it would be good to know exactly how Joomla 4 works / should work
- As it appears from the thread, right now Joomla Team should clarify some things (first of all to themselves)
- therefore I have highlighted my GitHub post here...

No controversy here, I've just tried to provide as much data as possible to make the best decisions and simplify the "fixing works"
Social Stream
Hide. Seek. Play!

Countdown Hide & Seek Game

Countdown, the new hide & seek toy, is available now! Designed and developed by the founders of SourceCoast, it's the perfect toy to get your kids moving at all ages.

Get the Hide and Seek Toy on Amazon