Now, I am pretty sure each of these was published BEFORE channels was set up, so it is possible that the channels system did not note these articles as previously posting to the networks so it was as if it was posting for the first time. Thoughts on this as the reason?
Yes, this is the culprit. JFBConnect has an autopost activity table in the database. When an article is saved, published, pending date changes, etc, we check the table to see if an auto-post activity has previously been recorded. Since you published the articles before the channel and auto-posting was set up, there would be no activity found in that table once you saved the article again with the tag.
Just to double-check, you can go into the JFBConnect backend > Channels > History tab to see all previous history. This last auto-post that you're seeing should be the only activity for the articles. This would confirm the above.
-Melissa