mtatem: Did you fix your issue? I'm seeing the FB Connect button now. Though, I am getting the cross-domain receiver error if I follow your link. Try reading this post to fix that problem:
<!-- m --><a class="postlink" href="
www.cmsmarket.com/forum/index.php?f=38&t=102&rb_v=viewtopic">
www.cmsmarket.com/forum/index.ph ... =viewtopic
Generally, if a template fixes the problem, it's because the 'bad' template is doing something it shouldn't be with Mootools. Either not allowing it to be loaded, or including a different version than what comes with Joomla. Try looking into that, and if you need help, just let us know.