Ben,
From a quick look at your front-end, it looks like you've set the Position setting to "Float". This will float it to the side/top of your screen like I'm seeing on your page. Try switching the Position setting to the "Fixed". This will put it into the module position you specify.
If you do change your mind and want it to float, you can also change the margin, padding, and float position settings. You can see an example of it floated on sourcecoast.com
Let me know if you need further help going forward after trying this.
-Melissa Andreae