Troy,
With the 4.1.0 release, we heard a few issues of redirect issues when the settings are configured to leave the user on the same page. We're working on a fix for the v4.1.1 release, due out next week. Until then, if you set the redirection to a specific menu item, it should prevent the redirection issue.
Please try changing your settings, temporarily, and we'll have an update out shortly that should allow you to change the redirection settings back.
Thanks,
Alex