Andrea,
No problem about the support, it's what we do. Thank you for your subscription, it's what allows us to do it!
Looking at your page, I see one instance of the fb:like tag (if I look at the HTML). In this tag, you'll see there's an href=http://www.gothicengine.com parameter. You should be able to easily replace this with the JFBCLike module with the following parameters:
Layout Style: Box Count
Show Face: No
Width: 100
- OR - the following tag:
{JFBCLike url=http://www.gothicengine.com layout=box_count show_faces=false width=100}
You can simply copy that tag above into a Custom HTML module or your template to insert it.
Please note, in both cases above, the URL is hard-coded to your home page, so if it's displayed on interior pages, and Like's will still be for the home page. This can be good.. or bad, depending on what you want. However, your Likes for the homepage (what the existing Like button is for) should remain intact.
Hope this helps, but if you have any problems, just let us know!